Oscar Silferstjerna
Kättare
Som jag har skrivit i ett par andra trådar har jag funderat över hur bestiarier kan göras mer användbara. Nedan ser ni några av de frågor som jag ställde - och de svar som ChatGPT gav. Diskussionen börjar mer allmänt för att sedan vinklas mot OSR och indie. Tycker att flera av svaren blev riktigt intressanta. Det blev tydligt hur olika stilar kan leda till helt olika typer av bestiarier. Kanske kan leda vidare till en diskussion här?
Is it fair to say that many RPG bestiaries could be more user-friendly?
Yes, it's fair to say that many RPG bestiaries could benefit from being more user-friendly. While traditional bestiaries typically focus on providing detailed statistics, abilities, and descriptions of creatures, they often lack user-friendly features that enhance accessibility, usability, and overall player experience. Here are some ways in which RPG bestiaries could be made more user-friendly:
1. Organization: Bestiaries could be organized in a more intuitive and user-friendly manner, with creatures grouped by type, environment, or challenge level for easy reference. Clear headings, subheadings, and indexes can help players quickly find the information they need during gameplay.
2. Formatting:Bestiaries could employ clear and consistent formatting that makes it easy to distinguish between different sections, abilities, and statistics. Bullet points, tables, and icons can help streamline information and improve readability.
3. Language: Bestiaries could use clear and concise language that is easy for players to understand, avoiding jargon, technical terminology, or overly complex descriptions that may confuse or overwhelm readers.
4. Visual Aids: Bestiaries could incorporate visual aids such as illustrations, diagrams, or maps to enhance comprehension and immersion. Visual representations of creatures and their habitats can help players visualize the game world and better understand the creatures they encounter.
5. Contextual Information: Bestiaries could provide context and background information about creatures, including their origins, behaviors, and cultural significance. This additional context helps players understand the role of creatures within the game world and enriches their overall gaming experience.
6. Narrative Integration: Bestiaries could integrate creatures into the broader narrative of the game world, providing story hooks, plot twists, and character motivations that tie into the creatures' lore and mythology. This narrative integration enhances immersion and player engagement.
7. Player Resources: Bestiaries could include player resources such as handouts, maps, and character sheets that facilitate gameplay and enhance the overall user experience. These resources help players stay organized, focused, and immersed in the game world.
8. Accessibility Features: Bestiaries could incorporate accessibility features such as alternative text, screen reader compatibility, and adjustable font sizes to accommodate players with diverse needs and preferences. Making bestiaries more accessible ensures that all players can fully enjoy and participate in the gaming experience.
Overall, by prioritizing user-friendly design principles such as organization, formatting, language, visual aids, context, narrative integration, player resources, and accessibility features, RPG bestiaries can become more accessible, intuitive, and enjoyable for players of all skill levels and backgrounds.
What would a user-friendly OSR bestiary be like?
A user-friendly OSR (Old School Renaissance) bestiary would prioritize simplicity, accessibility, and ease of use while capturing the spirit of classic RPGs. Here are some key features and characteristics that such a bestiary might include:
1. Simplified Stat Blocks: Creature stat blocks would be concise and easy to read, focusing on essential information such as hit points, armor class, attack bonuses, and damage dice. Extraneous details would be kept to a minimum to streamline gameplay.
2. Clear Descriptions: Creature descriptions would be straightforward and evocative, providing players with a clear sense of each creature's appearance, behavior, and abilities without unnecessary verbosity or complexity.
3. Iconography: Visual icons or symbols could be used to represent key creature traits or abilities, making it easy for players to quickly identify important information at a glance.
4. Random Encounter Tables: The bestiary might include random encounter tables tailored to different environments, offering a variety of creature encounters suitable for wilderness exploration, dungeon delving, or urban adventures.
5. *Thematic Grouping: Creatures could be grouped thematically or by habitat, allowing players to easily find creatures that are appropriate for specific campaign settings or scenarios.
6. *Adventure Hooks: Each creature entry might include adventure hooks or plot ideas related to the creature, inspiring Game Masters (GMs) to incorporate them into their own campaigns and adventures.
7. Artwork: Illustrations or sketches of creatures could accompany each entry, helping to visualize the creatures and enhance immersion for players.
8. Modular Design: The bestiary might be designed in a modular format, allowing GMs to easily customize and adapt creature entries to suit their own gaming preferences and house rules.
9. Player-Friendly Layout: The layout of the bestiary would be designed with players in mind, with clear headings, subheadings, and navigation features to make it easy to find and reference information during gameplay.
10. Open Licensing: The bestiary could be released under an open license, allowing for community contributions, modifications, and adaptations by other creators within the OSR community.
Overall, a user-friendly OSR bestiary would prioritize simplicity, accessibility, and ease of use, while providing GMs and players with a diverse array of classic creatures to encounter and explore in their adventures. It would capture the essence of classic RPGs while embracing modern design principles and accessibility features.
If you did the same for a an indie RPG bestiary, what would it be like? By indie I mean stuff like the games by creators like Vincent D Baker, Luke Crane and Ron Edwards.
Creating a bestiary for an indie RPG, such as those created by Vincent D. Baker, Luke Crane, or Ron Edwards, would involve a unique approach tailored to the specific themes, mechanics, and narrative styles of each game. While indie RPGs often prioritize narrative-driven gameplay, player agency, and innovative mechanics, the bestiary would reflect these principles while providing resources for GMs to create compelling and dynamic encounters. Here's how a bestiary for an indie RPG might differ from traditional RPG bestiaries:
1. Narrative Emphasis: The bestiary would focus on creatures that enhance the narrative and thematic elements of the game, rather than simply providing combat encounters. Each creature would have a rich backstory, motivations, and relationships with other elements of the game world.
2. Player Interaction: Creatures would be designed to encourage player interaction and exploration, offering opportunities for roleplaying, negotiation, and creative problem-solving. Combat might not always be the primary or preferred method of dealing with creatures.
3. Modular Design: The bestiary would feature modular creature designs that allow GMs to customize and adapt creatures to suit their specific campaigns and playstyles. Creatures might have customizable traits, abilities, and behaviors that can be tailored to fit different narrative needs.
4. Player-Driven Content: The bestiary might include mechanisms for players to contribute to the creation of creatures, such as collaborative world-building exercises or player-generated content submissions. This fosters a sense of ownership and investment in the game world.
5. Mechanical Integration: Creatures would be integrated with the game's mechanics in meaningful ways, offering mechanical benefits, challenges, or consequences based on player interactions. This ensures that creatures are not just narrative elements, but also integral components of the game system.
6. Artistic Expression: The bestiary would feature evocative artwork and visual representations of creatures that capture the unique aesthetic and tone of the game. Artwork might prioritize mood, atmosphere, and storytelling over realism or detail.
7. Narrative Hooks: Each creature entry would include narrative hooks, plot seeds, or scenario ideas for GMs to incorporate into their campaigns. These hooks could tie into the game's overarching themes, story arcs, or character motivations.
8. Collaborative Tools: The bestiary might include collaborative tools or frameworks for GMs and players to co-create creatures together during gameplay sessions. This encourages collaborative storytelling and fosters a sense of shared ownership over the game world.
9. Accessibility Features: The bestiary would prioritize accessibility features such as alternative text, screen reader compatibility, and adjustable font sizes to ensure that all players can fully engage with the content.
Overall, a bestiary for an indie RPG would reflect the unique design principles, narrative focus, and collaborative ethos of the game, providing GMs and players with a toolkit for creating memorable and immersive encounters that enhance the storytelling experience.
Is it fair to say that many RPG bestiaries could be more user-friendly?
Yes, it's fair to say that many RPG bestiaries could benefit from being more user-friendly. While traditional bestiaries typically focus on providing detailed statistics, abilities, and descriptions of creatures, they often lack user-friendly features that enhance accessibility, usability, and overall player experience. Here are some ways in which RPG bestiaries could be made more user-friendly:
1. Organization: Bestiaries could be organized in a more intuitive and user-friendly manner, with creatures grouped by type, environment, or challenge level for easy reference. Clear headings, subheadings, and indexes can help players quickly find the information they need during gameplay.
2. Formatting:Bestiaries could employ clear and consistent formatting that makes it easy to distinguish between different sections, abilities, and statistics. Bullet points, tables, and icons can help streamline information and improve readability.
3. Language: Bestiaries could use clear and concise language that is easy for players to understand, avoiding jargon, technical terminology, or overly complex descriptions that may confuse or overwhelm readers.
4. Visual Aids: Bestiaries could incorporate visual aids such as illustrations, diagrams, or maps to enhance comprehension and immersion. Visual representations of creatures and their habitats can help players visualize the game world and better understand the creatures they encounter.
5. Contextual Information: Bestiaries could provide context and background information about creatures, including their origins, behaviors, and cultural significance. This additional context helps players understand the role of creatures within the game world and enriches their overall gaming experience.
6. Narrative Integration: Bestiaries could integrate creatures into the broader narrative of the game world, providing story hooks, plot twists, and character motivations that tie into the creatures' lore and mythology. This narrative integration enhances immersion and player engagement.
7. Player Resources: Bestiaries could include player resources such as handouts, maps, and character sheets that facilitate gameplay and enhance the overall user experience. These resources help players stay organized, focused, and immersed in the game world.
8. Accessibility Features: Bestiaries could incorporate accessibility features such as alternative text, screen reader compatibility, and adjustable font sizes to accommodate players with diverse needs and preferences. Making bestiaries more accessible ensures that all players can fully enjoy and participate in the gaming experience.
Overall, by prioritizing user-friendly design principles such as organization, formatting, language, visual aids, context, narrative integration, player resources, and accessibility features, RPG bestiaries can become more accessible, intuitive, and enjoyable for players of all skill levels and backgrounds.
What would a user-friendly OSR bestiary be like?
A user-friendly OSR (Old School Renaissance) bestiary would prioritize simplicity, accessibility, and ease of use while capturing the spirit of classic RPGs. Here are some key features and characteristics that such a bestiary might include:
1. Simplified Stat Blocks: Creature stat blocks would be concise and easy to read, focusing on essential information such as hit points, armor class, attack bonuses, and damage dice. Extraneous details would be kept to a minimum to streamline gameplay.
2. Clear Descriptions: Creature descriptions would be straightforward and evocative, providing players with a clear sense of each creature's appearance, behavior, and abilities without unnecessary verbosity or complexity.
3. Iconography: Visual icons or symbols could be used to represent key creature traits or abilities, making it easy for players to quickly identify important information at a glance.
4. Random Encounter Tables: The bestiary might include random encounter tables tailored to different environments, offering a variety of creature encounters suitable for wilderness exploration, dungeon delving, or urban adventures.
5. *Thematic Grouping: Creatures could be grouped thematically or by habitat, allowing players to easily find creatures that are appropriate for specific campaign settings or scenarios.
6. *Adventure Hooks: Each creature entry might include adventure hooks or plot ideas related to the creature, inspiring Game Masters (GMs) to incorporate them into their own campaigns and adventures.
7. Artwork: Illustrations or sketches of creatures could accompany each entry, helping to visualize the creatures and enhance immersion for players.
8. Modular Design: The bestiary might be designed in a modular format, allowing GMs to easily customize and adapt creature entries to suit their own gaming preferences and house rules.
9. Player-Friendly Layout: The layout of the bestiary would be designed with players in mind, with clear headings, subheadings, and navigation features to make it easy to find and reference information during gameplay.
10. Open Licensing: The bestiary could be released under an open license, allowing for community contributions, modifications, and adaptations by other creators within the OSR community.
Overall, a user-friendly OSR bestiary would prioritize simplicity, accessibility, and ease of use, while providing GMs and players with a diverse array of classic creatures to encounter and explore in their adventures. It would capture the essence of classic RPGs while embracing modern design principles and accessibility features.
If you did the same for a an indie RPG bestiary, what would it be like? By indie I mean stuff like the games by creators like Vincent D Baker, Luke Crane and Ron Edwards.
Creating a bestiary for an indie RPG, such as those created by Vincent D. Baker, Luke Crane, or Ron Edwards, would involve a unique approach tailored to the specific themes, mechanics, and narrative styles of each game. While indie RPGs often prioritize narrative-driven gameplay, player agency, and innovative mechanics, the bestiary would reflect these principles while providing resources for GMs to create compelling and dynamic encounters. Here's how a bestiary for an indie RPG might differ from traditional RPG bestiaries:
1. Narrative Emphasis: The bestiary would focus on creatures that enhance the narrative and thematic elements of the game, rather than simply providing combat encounters. Each creature would have a rich backstory, motivations, and relationships with other elements of the game world.
2. Player Interaction: Creatures would be designed to encourage player interaction and exploration, offering opportunities for roleplaying, negotiation, and creative problem-solving. Combat might not always be the primary or preferred method of dealing with creatures.
3. Modular Design: The bestiary would feature modular creature designs that allow GMs to customize and adapt creatures to suit their specific campaigns and playstyles. Creatures might have customizable traits, abilities, and behaviors that can be tailored to fit different narrative needs.
4. Player-Driven Content: The bestiary might include mechanisms for players to contribute to the creation of creatures, such as collaborative world-building exercises or player-generated content submissions. This fosters a sense of ownership and investment in the game world.
5. Mechanical Integration: Creatures would be integrated with the game's mechanics in meaningful ways, offering mechanical benefits, challenges, or consequences based on player interactions. This ensures that creatures are not just narrative elements, but also integral components of the game system.
6. Artistic Expression: The bestiary would feature evocative artwork and visual representations of creatures that capture the unique aesthetic and tone of the game. Artwork might prioritize mood, atmosphere, and storytelling over realism or detail.
7. Narrative Hooks: Each creature entry would include narrative hooks, plot seeds, or scenario ideas for GMs to incorporate into their campaigns. These hooks could tie into the game's overarching themes, story arcs, or character motivations.
8. Collaborative Tools: The bestiary might include collaborative tools or frameworks for GMs and players to co-create creatures together during gameplay sessions. This encourages collaborative storytelling and fosters a sense of shared ownership over the game world.
9. Accessibility Features: The bestiary would prioritize accessibility features such as alternative text, screen reader compatibility, and adjustable font sizes to ensure that all players can fully engage with the content.
Overall, a bestiary for an indie RPG would reflect the unique design principles, narrative focus, and collaborative ethos of the game, providing GMs and players with a toolkit for creating memorable and immersive encounters that enhance the storytelling experience.
Last edited:
